Wednesday Fact Series - NIMBY

Posted by Tyler Moses On August - 19 - 2009

[Approx. Read Time: 2 minutes]

beachgoersMyth: People don’t want Nuclear power plants in their backyards

Where do I even start? This is an enormous myth. I was pleased last week to find that Bisconti Research Inc. made public their Nuclear Plant Neighbor Survey results because it makes my job in disproving this myth embarrassingly easy.

The Nuclear Plant Neighbor Survey used a sample of 1,100 adults living within 10 miles of one of our nation’s 64 nuclear plant sites. Plant employees living within ten miles of a site were not surveyed. Below are some of the results worth highlighting:

  • 84% of Americans living near nuclear power plants favor nuclear energy!
  • 90% view the local nuclear power station positively!
  • 76% would support the construction of a new reactor near them!
  • 72% associate nuclear energy “a lot” with reliability!
  • 71% have heard or read about the clean-air benefits of nuclear energy!
  • 58% strongly support nuclear energy whereas only 5% strongly oppose!
  • 83% believe that companies that own sites are involved in the community!

Wow! Nuclear plant neighbors are not only happy with the plants, but they wouldn’t even mind more reactors being constructed on site. These survey results really point out what great stewards domestic nuclear sites are within their respective communities. It doesn’t hurt that no member of the general public has ever been killed as a result of nuclear power plant operation something even wind turbines can’t claim.

Separate from the survey, I also wanted to take a more in depth look at another argument made by the “not in my backyard” crowd. Some residents have expressed worry that nuclear power plants could drive down home prices and hurt nearby communities. I decided to take a look at home prices directly next to McGuire Nuclear Station outside of Charlotte, NC where the median home price is $169,000. Using Zillow.com, I scanned prices of homes that have recently sold or are for sale near McGuire Nuclear Power Station. I found that there are several houses within less than ten miles of the power plant that have recently sold for over $1 million. Some of Charlotte’s most wealthy residents are choosing to live near the plant. When people that can afford to live just about anywhere invest in a home that close to a plant it makes you wonder if the “driving down home prices and hurting communities” fear really carries any weight. And the answer is no.

I dug deeper and found a 2006 study by Roger Bedzek and Robert Wendling that specifically studied the impact of 7 nuclear sites on property values. The results of this study can be summed up in one excerpt:

“The taxes and fees the facilities pay often fund over half of the county and school district budgets and provide levels of public and educational services that are far above those of surrounding counties and greater than the state averages. In each of the seven regions, housing and real estate values have benefited from the operations of the nuclear facilities.”

If nuclear power plants make for better schools and higher property values you can put one in my backyard today!

college-shirt( By Carrington Dillon )

I found this poll (courtesy of Zogby International) a while back while searching for material to stash in my Favorites for this website.  After seeing some polling data previously, I thought that most of the polling data was typical and to be expected.  However, something just came off the screen and really hit me in the face.  One piece of data… 18-24 year olds were the least supportive age group for nuclear power!

Only 47% of 18-24 year olds were supportive of building new nuclear plants.  67% of adults are supportive of nuclear power and 78% of those over the age of 65 are supportive.  The technology generation is against one of the most advanced technologies that the human race has ever created.  Is it popular culture, video games, rap music?

There are so many things that went through my head for a couple of days after I saw this.  But instead of telling you what I think is the reason for this trend, I’d like to try something new.  I’d like for my fellow NA-YGN members to comment and let me know what they think the cause is.  I would also like for them to come up with some ideas on how we can reach this college-aged group.

We may be able to use some of these ideas for our advocacy efforts in the future.  Recently, I have been working with others in NA-YGN on ideas to reach school-aged kids with nuclear advocacy.  This will go along perfectly with those efforts and hopefully create some good ideas in the process.  Feel free to let loose with the discussion.  Let’s see what you can come up with.

Fact Sheet 2009